Advertisement

Sleep-deprived motor vehicle operators are unfit to drive: a multidisciplinary expert consensus statement on drowsy driving

      Abstract

      Objectives

      This article presents the consensus findings of the National Sleep Foundation Drowsy Driving Consensus Working Group, which was an expert panel assembled to establish a consensus statement regarding sleep-related driving impairment.

      Methods

      The National Sleep Foundation assembled a expert panel comprised of experts from the sleep community and experts appointed by stakeholder organizations. A systematic literature review identified 346 studies that were abstracted and provided to the panelists for review. A modified Delphi RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Method with 2 rounds of voting was used to reach consensus.

      Results

      A final consensus was reached that sleep deprivation renders motorists unfit to drive a motor vehicle. After reviewing growing evidence of impairment and increased crash risk among drivers who obtained less than optimal sleep duration in the preceding 24 hours, the panelists recognized the need for public policy guidance as to when it is certainly unsafe to drive. Toward this end, the panelists agreed upon the following expert consensus statement: “Drivers who have slept for two hours or less in the preceding 24 hours are not fit to operate a motor vehicle.” Panelists further agreed that most healthy drivers would likely be impaired with only 3 to 5 hours of sleep during the prior 24 hours.

      Conclusions

      There is consensus among experts that healthy individuals who have slept for 2 hours or less in the preceding 24 hours are too impaired to safely operate a motor vehicle. Prevention of drowsy driving will require sustained and collaborative effort from multiple stakeholders. Implications and limitations of the consensus recommendations are discussed.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to Sleep Health: Journal of the National Sleep Foundation
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • McKnight-Eily L.R.
        • Liu Y.
        • Perry G.S.
        • et al.
        Perceived insufficient rest or sleep among adults—United States, 2008.
        MMWR. 2009; 58: 1175-1179
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Duration, timing and quality of sleep are each vital for health, performance and safety.
        Sleep Health. 2015; 1: 5-8https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleh.2014.12
        • Roehrs T.
        • Burduvali E.
        • Bonahoom A.
        • Drake C.
        • Roth T.
        Ethanol and sleep loss: a “dose” comparison of impairing effects.
        Sleep. 2003; 26: 981-985
        • Van Dongen H.P.A.
        • Maislin G.
        • Mullington J.M.
        • Dinges D.F.
        The cumulative cost of additional wakefulness: dose-response effects on neurobehavioral functions and sleep physiology from chronic sleep restriction and total sleep deprivation.
        Sleep. 2003; 26: 117-126
        • Powell N.B.
        • Schechtman K.B.
        • Riley R.W.
        • Li K.
        • Troell R.
        • Guilleminault C.
        The road to danger: the comparative risks of driving while sleepy.
        Laryngoscope. 2001; 111: 887-893
        • Lee M.L.
        • Howard M.E.
        • Horrey M.J.
        • et al.
        High risk of near-crash driving events following night-shift work.
        Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2016; 113: 176-181
        • Cajochen C.
        • Khalsa S.B.
        • Wyatt J.K.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Dijk D.J.
        EEG and ocular correlates of circadian melatonin phase and human performance decrements during sleep loss.
        Am J Physiol. 1999; 277: R640-R649
        • Dorrian J.
        • Rogers N.L.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Psychomotor vigilance performance: neurocognitive assay sensitive to sleep loss.
        in: Kushida C.A. Sleep Deprivation. Clinical Issues, Pharmacology, and Sleep Loss Effects. Marcel Dekker, New York2005: 39-70
        • Lim J.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Sleep deprivation and vigilant attention.
        Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2008; 1129: 305-322
        • Anderson C.
        • Wales A.W..
        • Horne J.A.
        PVT lapses differ according to eyes open, closed, or looking away.
        Sleep. 2010; 33: 197-204
        • Sanders A.F.
        • Reitsma W.D.
        The effect of sleep-loss on processing information in the functional visual field.
        Acta Psychol. 1982; 51: 149-162
        • Horowitz T.S.
        • Cade B.E.
        • Wolfe J.M.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Searching night and day: a dissociation of effects of circadian phase and time awake on visual selective attention and vigilance.
        Psychol Sci. 2003; 14: 549-557
        • Rogé J.
        • Pébayle T.
        • El Hannachi S.
        • Muzet A.
        Effect of sleep deprivation and driving duration on the useful visual field in younger and older subjects during simulator driving.
        Vis Res. 2003; 43: 1465-1472
        • Russo M.B.
        • Kendall A.P.
        • Johnson D.E.
        • Sing H.C.
        • Thorne D.R.
        • Escolas S.M.
        • et al.
        Visual perception, psychomotor performance, and complex motor performance during an overnight air refueling simulated flight.
        Aviat Space Environ Med. 2005; 76: C92-C103
        • Kendall A.P.
        • Kautz M.A.
        • Russo M.B.
        • Killgore W.D.
        • et al.
        Effects of sleep deprivation on lateral visual attention.
        Int J Neurosci. 2006; 116: 1125-1138
        • Santhi N.
        • Horowitz T.S.
        • Duffy J.F.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Acute sleep deprivation and circadian misalignment associated with transition onto the first night of work impairs visual selective attention.
        PLoS One. 2007; 2: e1233
        • Anderson C.
        • Horne J.A.
        Sleepiness enhances distraction during a monotonous task.
        Sleep. 2006; 29: 573-576
        • Turner T.H.
        • Drummond S.P.
        • Salamat J.S.
        • Brown G.G.
        Effects of 42 hr of total sleep deprivation on component processes of verbal working memory.
        Neuropsychology. 2007; 21: 787-795
        • Doran S.M.
        • Van Dongen H.P.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Sustained attention performance during sleep deprivation: evidence of state instability.
        Arch Ital Biol. 2001; 139: 253-267
        • Durmer J.S.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Neurocognitive consequences of sleep deprivation.
        Semin Neurol. 2005; 25: 117-129
        • Goel N.
        • Rao H.
        • Durmer J.S.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Neurocognitive consequences of sleep deprivation.
        Semin Neurol. 2009; 29: 320-339
        • Ratcliff R.
        • Van Dongen H.P.
        Sleep deprivation affects multiple distinct cognitive processes.
        Psychon Bull Rev. 2009; 16: 742-751
        • Banks S.
        • Dinges D.F.
        Behavioral and physiological consequences of sleep restriction.
        J Clin Sleep Med. 2007; 3: 519-528
        • Verster J.C.
        • Taillard J.
        • Sagaspe P.
        • Olivier B.
        • Philip P.
        Prolonged nocturnal driving can be as dangerous as severe alcohol-impaired driving.
        J Sleep Res. 2011; 20: 585-588
        • Bocca M.L.
        • Denise P.
        Total sleep deprivation effect on disengagement of spatial attention as assessed by saccadic eye movements.
        Clin Neurophysiol. 2006; 117: 894-899
        • Venkatraman V.
        • Chuah Y.M.
        • Huettel S.A.
        • Chee M.W.
        Sleep deprivation elevates expectation of gains and attenuates response to losses following risky decisions.
        Sleep. 2007; 30: 603-609
        • Dawson D.
        • Reid K.
        Fatigue, alcohol and performance impairment.
        Nature. 1997; 388: 235
        • Lamond N.
        • Dawson D.
        Quantifying the performance impairment associated with fatigue.
        J Sleep Res. 1999; 8: 255-262
        • Williamson A.M.
        • Feyer A.M.
        Moderate sleep deprivation produces impairments in cognitive and motor performance equivalent to legally prescribed levels of alcohol intoxication.
        Occup Environ Med. 2000; 57: 649-655
        • Falleti M.G.
        • Maruff P.
        • Collie A.
        • Darby D.G.
        • McStephen M.
        Qualitative similarities in cognitive impairment associated with 24 h of sustained wakefulness and a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05%.
        J Sleep Res. 2003; 12: 265-274
        • Babkoff H.
        • Zukerman G.
        • Fostick L.
        • Ben-Artzi E.
        Effect of the diurnal rhythm and 24 h of sleep deprivation on dichotic temporal order judgment.
        J Sleep Res. 2005; 14: 7-15
        • Killgore W.D.
        • Killgore D.B.
        • Day L.M.
        • Li C.
        • Kamimori G.H.
        • Balkin T.J.
        The effects of 53 hours of sleep deprivation on moral judgment.
        Sleep. 2007; 30: 345-352
        • Anderson C.
        • Dickinson D.L.
        Bargaining and trust: the effects of 36-h total sleep deprivation on socially interactive decisions.
        J Sleep Res. 2010; 19: 54-63
        • Killgore W.D.
        • Balkin T.J.
        • Wesensten N.J.
        Impaired decision making following 49 h of sleep deprivation.
        J Sleep Res. 2006; 15: 7-13
        • McKenna B.S.
        • Dickinson D.L.
        • Orff H.J.
        • Drummond S.P.
        The effects of one night of sleep deprivation on known-risk and ambiguous-risk decisions.
        J Sleep Res. 2007; 16: 245-252
        • Killgore W.D.
        • Grugle N.L.
        • Balkin T.J.
        Gambling when sleep deprived: don't bet on stimulants.
        Chronobiol Int. 2012; 29: 43-54
        • Powell N.B.
        • Chau J.K.
        Sleepy driving.
        Med Clin North Am. 2010; 94: 531-540
        • Connor J.
        • Norton R.
        • Ameratunga S.
        • et al.
        Driver sleepiness and risk of serious injury to car occupants: population based case control study.
        BMJ. 2002; 324: 1125
        • Tefft B.
        Prevalence of Motor Vehicle Crashes Involving Drowsy Drivers, United States, 2009-2013.
        AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, Washington, DC2014
        • Dingus T.A.
        • Klauer S.G.
        • Neale V.L.
        • et al.
        The 100-Car Naturalistic Driving Study; Phase II-Results of the 100-Car Field Experiment.
        National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, DC2006
        • Masten S.
        • Stutts J.
        • Martell C.
        Predicting daytime and nighttime drowsy driving crashes based on crash characteristic models.
        in: 50th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine. 2006
        • Fitch K.
        • Bernstein S.J.
        • Aguilar M.D.
        • et al.
        The RAND/UCLA appropriateness method user's manual.
        2001
        • Aeschbach D.
        • Cajochen C.
        • Landolt H.-P.
        • Borbély A.A.
        Homeostatic sleep regulation in habitual short sleepers and long sleepers.
        Am J Physiol. 1996; 270: R41-R53
        • Shekleton J.A.
        • Rajaratnam S.M.W.
        • Gooley J.J.
        • Van Reen E.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Lockley S.W.
        Improved neurobehavioral performance during the wake maintenance zone.
        J Clin Sleep Med. 2013; 9: 353-362
        • Pack A.I.
        • Pack A.M.
        • Rodgman E.
        • Cucchiara A.
        • Dinges D.F.
        • Schwab C.W.
        Characteristics of crashes attributed to the driver having fallen asleep.
        Accid Anal Prev. 1995; 27: 769-775
        • Mitler M.M.
        • Carskadon M.A.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Dement W.C.
        • Dinges D.F.
        • Graeber R.C.
        Catastrophes, sleep, and public policy: consensus report.
        Sleep. 1988; 11: 100-109
        • Campbell S.S.
        • Dijk D.J.
        • Boulos Z.
        • Eastman C.I.
        • Lewy A.J.
        • Terman M.
        Light treatment for sleep disorders: consensus report. III. Alerting and activating effects.
        J Biol Rhythms. 1995; 10: 129-132
        • Lockley S.W.
        • Evans E.E.
        • Scheer F.A.J.L.
        • Brainard G.C.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Aeschbach D.
        Short-wavelength sensitivity for the direct effects of light on alertness, vigilance, and the waking electroencephalogram in humans.
        Sleep. 2006; 29: 161-168
        • Rahman S.A.
        • Flynn-Evans E.E.
        • Aeschbach D.
        • Brainard G.C.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Lockley S.W.
        Diurnal spectral sensitivity of the acute alerting effects of light.
        Sleep. 2014; 37: 271-281
        • Urry E.
        • Landolt H.P.
        Adenosine, caffeine, and performance: from cognitive neuroscience of sleep to sleep pharmacogenetics.
        Curr Top Behav Neurosci. 2015; 25: 331-366
        • Wyatt J.K.
        • Cajochen C.
        • Ritz-De Cecco A.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Dijk D.J.
        Low-dose repeated caffeine administration for circadian-phase–dependent performance degradation during extended wakefulness.
        Sleep. 2004; 27: 374-381
        • Wesensten N.J.
        • Killgore W.D.
        • Balkin T.J.
        Performance and alertness effects of caffeine, dextroamphetamine, and modafinil during sleep deprivation.
        J Sleep Res. 2005; 14: 255-266
        • Czeisler C.A.
        • Walsh J.K.
        • Roth T.
        • et al.
        Modafinil for excessive sleepiness associated with shift work sleep disorder.
        N Engl J Med. 2005; 353: 476-486
        • Grady S.
        • Aeschbach D.
        • Wright Jr., K.P.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Effect of modafinil on impairments in neurobehavioral performance and learning associated with extended wakefulness and circadian misalignment.
        Neuropsychopharmacology. 2010; 35: 1910-1920
        • Drake C.
        • Roehrs T.
        • Breslau N.
        • et al.
        The 10-year risk of verified motor vehicle crashes in relation to physiologic sleepiness.
        Sleep. 2010; 33: 745-752
        • Herman J.
        • Kafoa B.
        • Wainiqolo I.
        • et al.
        Driver sleepiness and risk of motor vehicle crash injuries: a population-based case control study in Fiji (TRIP 12).
        Injury. 2014; 45: 586-591
        • Philip P.
        • Chaufton C.
        • Orriols L.
        • et al.
        Complaints of poor sleep and risk of traffic accidents: a population-based case-control study.
        PLoS One. 2014; 9: e114102
        • Czeisler C.A.
        The Gordon Wilson Lecture: work hours, sleep and patient safety in residency training.
        Trans Am Clin Climatol Assoc. 2006; 117: 159-188
        • Duffy J.F.
        • Zitting K.M.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        The case for addressing operator fatigue.
        Rev Hum Factors Ergon. 2015; 10: 29-78
        • Colten H.
        • Altevogt B.
        Institute of Medicine (US): Committee on Sleep Medicine and Research. Sleep disorders and sleep deprivation: an unmet public health problem.
        Institute of Medicine: National Academies Press, Washington, DC2006
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Medical and genetic differences in the adverse impact of sleep loss on performance: ethical considerations for the medical profession.
        Trans Am Clin Climatol Assoc. 2009; 120: 249-285
        • Czeisler C.
        President's message.
        SRS Bull. 2005; 11: 4
        • Rajaratnam S.M.
        • Landrigan C.P.
        • Wang W.
        • Kaprielian R.
        • Moore R.T.
        • Czeisler C.A.
        Teen crashes declined after Massachusetts raised penalties for graduated licensing law restricting night driving.
        Health Aff (Millwood). 2015; 34: 963-970https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff